Abstract
The Giunti Odeon in Florence is a remarkable case study when rethinking the relationships and boundaries between heritage and innovation. The contribution will deal with a modern heritage and the concept of innovation will refer to its technical aspects but above all to its cultural and theoretical dimensions. Due to the Covid-19 pandemic, the former Cinema-Theatre housed in Palazzo dello Strozzino underwent a financial crisis. The latter has represented the opportunity to reinvent this place, a heritage protected by the Ministry of Culture and deeply rooted in the collective memory of the inhabitants of Florence who fought to defend the cinema’s function. Following its opening to the public in 2023, the majestic space restored by Studio Benaim houses in an almost sacred atmosphere a cinema and a bookshop that seem to define an extension of the outdoor public spaces. The complexity of the proposed programme, addressed through a project that appears rigorously elementary, is the strength of a proposal capable of combining economic sustainability, social demands and above all architectural values. The two functions overlap in the central space of the ancient palace inducing silence and respect for the users while working, eating, shopping, reading, watching films or just wandering. Considering that the uncontrolled diffusion of streaming platforms for movies and series has put the Foucauldian heterotopia of cinema currently at risk of disappearing, beyond the various and valuable adaptive reuses of underused architectures as movie theatres, Studio Benaim’s Giunti Odeon appears as a spatialisation of the concept of “hypertopia”. In this sense, the case study will be discussed to demonstrate how a different and inno-vative approach to the modern heritage of heterotopias is possible if the boundaries of design are challenged through a complex design approach that demonstrates a cultural innovation that enhances differences and promotes coexistence.
Download
Cite this article
Vannelli, G. (2025). Giunti Odeon in Florence: An Hypertopia Challenging the Boundaries Between Heritage and Innovation. In Architectural Experiences, 1, (pp. 270-273). Editura Universitară Ion Mincu
References
- D. Abramson, Obsolescence. An architectural history (The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 2016).
- G. Vannelli, “Da luoghi della produzione alla produzione di luoghi. Interpretazioni e strategie progettuali,” in Stati Generali del Patrimonio Industriale 2022, edited by E. Currà, M. Docci, C. Menichelli, M. Russo, L. Severi (Marsilio, Venezia, 2022), 9.0.2.
- G. Vannelli and A. D’Agostino, “Hypertopia. Challenging cemeteries idea: historical urban outposts between preservation and transformation,” in ISUF 2023 PRAXIS OF URBAN MORPHOLOGY: Conference Proceedings Part II, edited by V. Djokić, A. Djordjević, M. Pešić, M. Milojević, A. Milovanović (University of Belgrade – Faculty of Architecture, Belgrade, 2023), pp. 1174-1184.
- G. Vannelli and G. D’Ascoli, “Obsolescenze e recinti. Il Leonardo Bianchi, refugia per una Napoli a venire,” in Roma, capitale d’Italia. 150 anni dopo. vol. 1, Centri stori-ci urbani. Luoghi di culto, edited by C. Bellanca, S. M. Alonso-Munoyerro (Artemide, Roma, 2021), pp. 197-207.
- G. Vannelli, “Think outside the box. Towards new transient morphologies: The case of post-emergency housing,” in XXIX International Seminar on Urban Form. ISUF 2022 Urban Redevelopment and Revitalisation. A Multidisciplinary Perspective, edited by A.A. Kantarek M. Hanzl T. Figlus Ł. Musiaka (Lodz University of Technolo-gy Press, Lodz, 2023), pp. 1634-1649.
- P. Sloterdijk, Sfere III. Schiume (Raffello Cortina Editore, Milano, 2015).
- G. Laino, “Tavolo 6. Beni comuni e pratiche comunitarie,” in Changing cities. Temi, competenze, alleanze per le città di domani, edited by P. Piscitelli (Fondazione Giangiacomo Feltrinelli, Milano, 2018), pp. 53-58.
- V. Magnago Lampugnani, Contro la città usa e getta. Per una cultura del costruire sostenibile (Bollati Boringhieri, Torino, 2024).
- M. L. Nobile, Reuse, regenerate, reactivate : Strategies for the contemporary city. The URBACT programme and Naples (Edizioni Caracol, Palermo, 2024).
- P. Cerri, R. Giovannoli and F. Neeff, “Recinti”, Rassegna 1, 7–32 (1979).
- T. Winter, “Clarifying the critical in critical heritage studies”, International Journal of Heritage Studies 19(6), 532–545 (2012).
- P. Simay, Bâtir avec ce qui reste, Quelles ressources pour sortir de l’extractivisme ? (Terre Urbaine, Condé-en-Normandie, 2024).
- M. Foucault, “Des espaces autres,” in Dits et écrits IV, (Gallimard, Paris, 1967), pp. 752-762.
- F. Casetti, The Lumière Galaxy: Seven Key Words for the Cinema to Come (Columbia University Press, New York, 2015). 2.
- F. Moschini, “Architecture and cinema: visionary places,” in Territori del cinema: stanze, luoghi, paesaggi. Un sistema per la Puglia. Letture e interpretazioni, edited by V. Ieva, F. Maggiore (Gangemi Editore, Rome, 2013), pp. 41-56.
- A. Somaini, “Cinema,” in Architettura del Novecento. Teorie, scuole, eventi, edit-ed by M. Biraghi, A. Ferlenga (Giulio Einaudi Editore, Torino, 2012), pp. 133-144.
- A. Iacomoni, “Firenze: il cinema Odeon si rilancia come spazio multiculturale”; 2023 [Accessed 8 January 2025]. Available from: https://ilgiornaledellarchitettura/">https://ilgiornaledellarchitettura. com/2023/11/27/firenze-il-cinema-odeon-si-rilancia-come-spazio-multiculturale/
- E. Godoli and G. Belli, L’architettura italiana dei cinema. Opus incertum vol.2 (Polistampa, Firenze, 2007).
- L. Milan, “A Firenze, un cinema-libreria per la nuova vita del Cinema Teatro Odeon”; 2023 [Accessed 8 January 2025]. Available from: https://www.teknoring.com/">https://www.teknoring.com/news/riqualificazione-urbana/cinema-teatro-odeon-firenze-cinema-libreria/
- F. Casetti, Screening Fears: On Protective Media (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2023).
- C. Mezzabotta, “Il progetto di restauro del nuovo Giunti Odeon di Firenze”; 2023 [Accessed 8 January 2025]. Available from: https://www.area-arch.it/il-proget-">https://www.area-arch.it/il-proget-to-di-restauro-del-nuovo-giunti-odeon-di-firenze/
Issue contents
pp. 20-25
pp. 26-31
pp. 32-35
pp. 36-39
pp. 40-43
pp. 44-49
pp. 50-53
pp. 58-63
pp. 74-79
pp. 80-85
pp. 92-97
pp. 104-109
pp. 110-113
pp. 114-119
pp. 120-123
pp. 128-133
pp. 134-139
pp. 140-143
pp. 144-147
pp. 164-171
pp. 178-183
pp. 184-191
pp. 236-241
pp. 252-255
pp. 260-265
pp. 266-269
pp. 270-273
pp. 274-279
pp. 280-285
pp. 290-295
pp. 296-301